CONSIGNMENT What We Accept & Typically Pass On

​​​​​​

 We accept a wide range of collectibles, but every item must have proven resale demand and must make sense based on value, condition, storage space, shipping cost, and the time required to research and sell it properly.

We primarily sell on eBay, so pricing and acceptance decisions are based on:

• Sold listings
• Average sold prices
• Active listings
• Sell-through trends

We do not base value on asking prices.

What We Mean By Resale Demand

Resale demand means an item not only has value, but sells consistently over time.

• Many listed, few sold → weak demand
• Some sell-through → moderate demand
• Sold listings close to active listings → strong demand

We prioritize items that sell regularly, not items that sit.

General Value Rules

Most individual items should have a resale value of around $25 or more to be sold individually.

Items between $10 and $20 will NOT be sold individually, but may still be accepted if they:

• Have real demand
• Can be grouped into strong, sellable lots

Items that sell for $10 or less are not accepted or purchased.

This applies to:

• Consignment
• Buyouts
• All categories

Condition Requirements

All items must be clean and ready to be listed.

We do not accept:

• Dirt
• Cobwebs
• Bugs
• Sticky residue
• Heavy grime
• Mold or mildew
• Moisture damage
• Strong odors

Light dust is acceptable (not preferred).
Heavy dust will NOT be accepted.

Shipping & Storage

• Smaller items are preferred
• Heavy items must justify shipping
• Oversized items may be sold locally​​

​

​

Advertising & Promotional Items

Examples

• Beer Advertising - Clocks, Signs, Advertising

• Gas & oil signs - Texaco, Mobil, Shell, Sinclair, Phillips 66

• Soda advertising - Coca-Cola, Pepsi, 7UP, Dr Pepper

• Store displays, racks, fixtures

• Restaurant advertising - McDonalds, Pizza Hut, Chuck E. Cheese

• Advertising tins

• Thermometers

​​

Details

• Older preferred

• Displayable condition required

• No reproduction items

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Antiques & Early Collectibles

Examples

• Cast iron banks

• Tobacco tins

• Shaving mugs

• Pocket watches & wristwatches

• Clocks - wall, mantle, advertising

• Small Americana

• Folk art

• Antique toy-related items

• Vintage Fishing Gear — Lures, Reels, Tackle, Tackle Boxes, Display Pieces, Advertising

​​

Details

• Older and unique required

• Smaller items preferred

• No reproduction items

• Modern replicas (1990s-present) generally not accepted

​​

​​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Art, Custom & Handmade Collectibles

Examples

• Custom figures

• Dioramas

• Pop culture artwork

• Handmade display pieces

​​

Details

• Must have real collector demand

• Recognizable characters preferred

• Quality craftsmanship matters

• Generic handmade items not accepted

​​

​​

​​​​​​​​​​Autographs & Signed Items

Examples

• Sports

• Movies

• Music

​​

Details

• COA required

• Beckett / PSA / JSA

​​

​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Belt Buckles

Some Examples Include

• Western belt buckles

• Advertising belt buckles

• Brand-name buckles

• Character buckles

• Rodeo buckles

• Vintage collectible buckles

• And More

​​

Details

• Older is preferred

• Displayable condition matters

• Branded, themed, or unique designs are strongest

• Common modern buckles are not the focus

​​​

​

Books

Examples

• Pop culture books

• Collector guides

• Horror / sci-fi

• Art books

• Gaming guides

​​

Details

• Must have demand​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Coins & Currency

Examples

• Morgan dollars

• Silver coins

• Star notes

​​

​

​Comic Books & Paper Collectibles

Examples

• Comics

• Key issues

• Graphic novels

• Posters

• Folders / paper goods

​​

Details

• Condition critical

​

​

​Electronics (Older Only)

Examples

• Handheld games

• Walkmans

• Radios

• iPods

​​

Details

• 15–20+ years old

• Must work

• Battery Compartment Not Corroded

​​​

​

​Farm Toys & Tractor Collectibles

Examples

• Ertl

• John Deere

• Dealer models

• Precision models

• Pedal tractors

​

Details

• No plastic tractors

• Pedal tractors likely sold locally

​

​

​Furniture (Small Only)

Examples

• Shelves

• Cabinets

• Store fixtures

​​

Details

• 1960s–70s and earlier preferred

• Must be unique

• Storage dependent

​

​​​

Holiday & Seasonal Collectibles

Examples

• Halloween masks, blow molds

• Vintage Christmas décor

• Older Hallmark ornaments

​​​​​

​

Lunchboxes, Thermoses & Character Containers

Some Examples Include

• Metal lunchboxes

• Character lunchboxes

• Character thermoses

• Branded food containers

• Vintage lunch totes

• Character carry cases

• And More

​​

Examples Of Themes

• TMNT

• GI Joe

• Ghostbusters

• Batman

• Walt Disney

• The Addams Family

• The Munsters

• Classic cartoons and movie characters

​​

Details

• 1980s and older preferred

• 1990s lunchboxes are generally weaker (mostly plastic, mass-produced)

• No modern replica lunchboxes

• No newly produced or mass-produced collector reproductions

• Condition matters heavily:

  • Clean graphics

  • Minimal rust

  • Solid hinges

  • Presentable condition

• Matching thermos adds value

​

​​​​​

Military, Firefighter & Service Memorabilia

Some Examples Include

• Military patches

• Military pins

• Named items

• Service medals -basic collectible level

• Firefighter badges

• Fire department memorabilia

• Police memorabilia

• Service-related collectibles

• Vintage service gear

• And More

​​

Details

• Smaller, displayable items preferred

• Historical or identifiable items are stronger

• Condition and authenticity matter

• Must have collector demand

​​

​

​Movie, TV & Character Memorabilia

Some Examples Include

• Movie merchandise

• TV show collectibles

• Character merchandise

• Theater promotional items

• Licensed collectibles

• Display pieces

• Character containers

• Character novelties

• Vintage fan merchandise

• And More

​​

Examples Of Themes

• Star Wars

• Batman

• Ghostbusters

• TMNT

• Disney

• Horror

• Classic TV shows

• Cartoon properties

​​

Details

• Older licensed items preferred

• Must have real collector demand

• Displayable items perform best

​​

​​

Pins, Patches, Buttons & Small Collectibles

Some Examples Include

• Enamel pins

• Advertising pins

• Character pins

• Military pins

• Vintage buttons

• Promotional buttons

• Cloth patches

• Biker patches

• Sports patches

• Collector patches

• Advertising pencils

• Character pencils

• Promotional pencils

• And More

​​

Details

• Older is preferred

• Must have collector or display value

• Character, advertising, and themed items perform best

• Random bulk low-value pins are not the focus

​

​

​​Records & Music Collectibles

Examples

• Vinyl records

• Band merch

• Concert posters

• Tour programs

​​

Details

• No cassettes

• Older preferred

​

​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​Shoes, Hats & Vintage Clothing

Examples

• Nike (80s–90s)

• Reebok

• No Fear shirts

• Band shirts

• TMNT / Batman / Power Rangers shirts

• Starter jackets

• Jordans

​

Details

• Must be clean

• Higher resale expected

​

​

​​​Sports Collectibles & Memorabilia

Examples

• Signed balls

• Vintage sports merchandise

• Programs

​

Details

• Older preferred

​

​​​

Toys

​

Action Figures

• GI Joe

• TMNT Vintage Star Wars

• Marvel

• DC

• Ghostbusters

• MMPR

• Motu

• Street Sharks, and more

• Custom figures, dioramas, handmade displays

​

Diecast Vehicles & Toy Vehicles

Some Examples Include

• Hot Wheels — Primarily 1960s–1980s (Redlines, early era cars)

• Matchbox — Lesney-era and older collector models

• Tonka — Metal trucks, construction vehicles, service vehicles

• Marx — Toy vehicles, play vehicles, character vehicles

• Johnny Lightning

• Greenlight

• M2 Machines

• Micro Machines

• Die-cast cars and trucks

• Service vehicles

• Character vehicles

• Toy trucks and construction vehicles

• And More

​​

Details

• Hot Wheels accepted up through the 1980s only

• No newer Hot Wheels will be accepted

• No NASCAR

• No sports team semis, cars, or themed sports vehicles

• No unnamed brand vehicles

• No modern mass-produced diecast (1990s–present)

• Older, collectible, and displayable pieces are preferred

• Tonka and Marx are strongest when they are older metal pieces

• Condition, rarity, and presentation matter

• Boxed or carded examples may carry stronger value

​​

European Toys

• Corgi

• Dinky

• Britains

• Action Force

​​

Japanese Toys

• Godzilla

• Shoguns

• Vinyl

• Imported figures

​​

LEGO

• Sealed sets - only (no loose sets)

• Minifigures Loose & New"

​

Mini Figures

Mighty Max, Polly Pocket, TMNT, Marvel, DC, MMPR

​

Plush & Dolls

My Little Pony, Cabbage Patch, Furbies, Jem, 1960s Barbie

​

Details

• Must be clean

• Stored properly

• No odor

• Hair/fur must be presentable

​

Railroad & Trains

• Engines

• Lanterns

• Signs

• Tickets

​

Transformers

• 1980s and smaller to midsize preferred

• Go-Bots

​

Vehicles & Playsets

Batmobile, Turtle Van, Technodrome

​

Vintage Toys (1920s+)

Wind-ups, early plastic toys, tin toys

​

Licensed Merchandise

Includes a wide range of character-based merchandise such as lunchboxes, school supplies, novelty items, containers, and branded accessories tied to popular franchises

​

Knockoffs, Prototypes & Test Pieces

KO figures, bootlegs, test shots, prototypes, factory samples

​

Details

• Must have collector demand

• Modern replicas generally not accepted

​​

​​

​Trading Cards

Examples

• Pokémon

• Magic

• Sports Cards

• Non-Sport Cards

​​

Details

• No junk wax era (late 1980s–mid 1990s)

• No dollar cards

• No cards under $15

• Cards must have real resale demand based on sold listings

• Bulk modern base cards are not accepted

​​

Sports Cards Specific:

• Cards from the late 1990s through 2020 may be accepted

​​

• Must include:

  • Star players

  • Key rookie cards

  • Numbered cards

  • Autographs

  • Relics / memorabilia cards

  • Low-print or limited cards

​​

• Large bulk lots of common cards from this era are not accepted

​​

​

​Video Games

CARTRIDGE ONLY

​

NES, SNES, N64, Switch, Game Boy, Sega

​

Details

• No Xbox / PlayStation / PC / Atari 

​

Not Sure?

If you're unsure whether your items qualify, review this page, then submit photos for review.

Submission Reminder

All consignments require photo review and pre-approval before drop-off.

Before submitting, review:

How The Process Works
Frequently Asked Questions

Continue reading below for items we do not accept before submitting.

​